Many applicants will have only 10 days, instead of 30, to appeal an adverse decision to the Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA). This final rule also reinstates several other restrictions on appeals to the BIA. The Department of Justice (DOJ) says these limits are justified by the large number of cases awaiting decision before the BIA: around 35,800 at the end of FY 2017, rising to over 325,000 at the end of FY 2026.

It takes effect on about December 17, 2026. It will not apply to existing cases. Any appeal already filed will continue to benefit from the 30-day time limit.

DOJ attempted to impose these restrictions by an interim rule in February 2026. A District Court in Washington, D.C., vacated several provisions in March 2026 because DOJ failed to allow notice and comment. After a comment period, the DOJ has now promulgated a final rule.

Principal Changes

As noted above, most appeals from a removal decision would be subject to a 10-day time limit. Appeals from certain asylum decisions would continue to have 30 days. Congress imposed this deadline, which applies only when the immigration judge decides an asylum application on its merits. For example, an applicant has only 10 days to appeal an order closing or dismissing removal proceedings because the applicant failed to file an asylum application within the one-year deadline.

All grounds for appeal must be outlined in the Notice of Appeal, and others will be deemed waived.

Perhaps most significantly, any appeal could be summarily dismissed after 15 days by one member of the entire Board, unless, within 10 days of receiving the Notice of Appeal, a majority of all regular members of the Board decide to review it. If not so reviewed, the decision of the IJ would stand as the decision of the agency. Presumably this would allow greater attention to issues warranting review by the full Board, for example, novel points of law.

Future developments

Further challenges seem likely. It has been widely criticized (for example, by AILA and Amica Center for Immigrant Rights) as particularly adversely affecting detained individuals, minors, those unable to speak English well, and the unrepresented. DOJ would argue that immigration judges afford adequate process to all, but that no constitutional right exists to appeal to the BIA.

There would, of course, remain a right to petition the appropriate Court of Appeals following a dismissal. However, it would normally be desirable for the BIA to consider and decide the relevant matters first. It could therefore be very difficult to raise new matters on a petition for review if not raised within 10 days. It would be prudent to seek advice promptly if subject to an order of removal after the middle of December 2026.

As always, ILBSG actively monitors ongoing U.S. immigration news. If you have questions about any U.S. immigration related issue, contact us. Working with an experienced attorney ensures you get the right advice based on the most recent laws. In an ever-evolving immigration policy landscape, it’s particularly critical you get the right advice.