On November 12, 2026, a D.C. federal district court judge heard oral argument in Nathan v. Trump regarding the administration’s second attempt to curtail birthright citizenship. The ACLU and co-plaintiffs initiated the suit in September 2026, a few months after the Supreme Court invalidated the first Executive Order.
Background
On June 30, 2026, in Trump v. Barbara, the Supreme Court held that EO 14160 was inconsistent with the 14th Amendment, which provided that babies born to undocumented parents or parents with only temporary lawful status would not be US citizens. The President signed two new executive orders on August 6, 2025. S. 14418 is titled “Continuing To Protect The Meaning And Value of American Citizenship”. The guidance directs federal agencies not to recognize the citizenship of some U.S.-born children when neither parent is a U.S. citizen, meaning a child is not protected by having a green card holder parent. The order said its list is not exhaustive. It applies to children whose parent:
- Is a member of a designated foreign terrorist organization (the order refers to these parents as “alien enemies”).
- Employed by a foreign government or an international organization entitled to immunity.
- Purchased or otherwise fraudulently obtained the child’s citizenship, such as by using a paid surrogate.
This also includes children born in U.S. territories where federal law does not provide citizenship at birth, such as American Samoa.
The second order, “Ending Birth Tourism,” directs the Department of State (DOS) and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) to stop people from entering on nonimmigrant visas to have a child in the United States. The relevant agencies would also be able to refuse to issue visas to these individuals or refuse them admission to the US, or to deport them. Anyone who facilitated such travel may be subject to the same action.
Hearing Details
Judge Christopher R. Cooper seemed doubtful of much of the government’s contentions during this case. Considerable time was spent on when the Order would take effect, given it does not specify an effective date. Attorneys representing the ACLU suggested it may apply to all children already born and result in the revocation of existing passports. One Department of Justice (DOJ) attorney conceded the Order would presumably not apply to a baby born two days prior to the Order being signed. Of course, this was only one lawyer’s interpretation. There is no reference to it anywhere in the body of the Order.
What Immigrants Need to Know
It’s too early to know if this second attempt will stick. The administration says the new categories fall within the narrow exceptions the Supreme Court recognized in Barbara. Challengers say it’s another way the government can run around that ruling.
As always, ILBSG continues to follow these cases closely. If you have questions about birthright citizenship or any other U.S. immigration issue, contact us. Policy is changing quickly, so it pays to get advice that reflects the most recent rulings. In an ever-changing immigration landscape, it’s particularly critical you get the right advice.
